# Evaluation rubric

Score each criterion 0–3 and attach evidence. A score without evidence is zero.

| Criterion | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| User value | No user/outcome | Claimed | Plausible | Demonstrated | |
| Correctness | Untested | Happy path | Fixed evaluation set | Includes failures/edge cases | |
| Traceability | No sources | Partial | Core claims linked | End-to-end traceable | |
| Safety/control | Unclear | Risks named | Controls applied | Failure/recovery shown | |
| Technical quality | Fragile | Runs once | Tested and reviewable | Fits team conventions | |
| Reuse/ownership | None | Notes | Reusable asset | Owner + next experiment | |

Decision: continue / reshape / stop

Reason and next action: